Best Smudge Proof Eyeliner for Oily Eyelids in 2023 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Best Smudge Proof Eyeliner for Oily Eyelids

Most problem of female when we talk about eyeliner is the mess it creates when it is not dry yet. In addition, these often happens to women with oily eyelids. That is why, best smudge proof eyeliner oily eyelids are made to rescue you from that mess.

This kind of eyeliner has the ability to stay dry in its place without making your eyes look like a ghost. Are you looking for the best eyeliner for hooded eyes or for your oily eyelids?

This article contained carefully chosen some perfect smudge proof eyeliner oily eyelids with a buying guide and top 7 product reviews.

Features of Smudge Proof Eyeliner for Oily Eyelids

Smudge proof eyeliner is different cosmetics from ordinary one. It offers more features for you to enjoy. Here are some of those:

Easy Cleanup

Unlike ordinary eyeliners, smudge proof type is easy to remove. They can be removed easily using makeup remover or even wet wipes when pressure is applied.

Moreover, majority of these type can be taken from the eyelid as easy as when you apply it. You can use a cotton pad with oil-based makeup remover. Then, gently press the cotton against your eyelid for 15 seconds.

Finally, wipe the eyeliner with downward stroke.

Save You from Raccoon Eyes

Smudge Proof Eyeliner for Oily Eyelids rescue you from having a raccoon eyes. This refers to the dark inks surrounding your eyes when eye makeups are smudge.

If you are using an ordinary eyeliner, naturally when sweat or unexpected rain comes, expect for a ghost like eyes. This type of eyeliner stays in it position even if you have an oily eyelids or sweaty one.

In addition, it has the potential to stay in your eyelids or waterline for long hours to avoid repeat application.

Long Lasting

This type of eyeliner is known to last longer. In other words, aside from you will be save from embarrassing situation when ink is smudge, this type is also design to stay in your lids for a long time.

If you are using the best waterproof eyeliner for waterline or best eye primer for oily lids, it will not disappear any time soon. In fact, there are some type of this eyeliner that needs make up remover before It disappears in your eyes.

In using this kind, you can make sure that your eyes will look great from morning until night.

Top 7 Smudge Proof Eyeliner Oily Eyelids Reviews

These following Smudge Proof Eyeliners for Oily Eyelids came from the top purchased and reviewed products.

To make your life convenience, we will help you look for the kind you should pick.

Here are the top 7 Eyeliners and their honest review.


This product is the leading US based makeup brand that the world loves. NYX Professional Makeup is well known by professional makeup artists and those who are makeup lovers.

Moreover, this Epic Ink Liner offers a long-lasting water proof effect. This best eyeliner for oily eyelids lasts all day long.

  • Easy to apply.
  • Affordable price.
  • Good for sensitive eyes.
  • Not smooth brush.

This best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids is perfect for you if sensitivity is your problem. Moreover, its affordable price is unbeatable and surely won’t hurt your pockets.

2. Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

This product is designed to give you a smudge free eyes. It accentuates your waterline and gives allure to your eye makeup. Moreover, this best smudge proof eyeliner for waterline stays even when you are sweat or crying maybe.

  • Stays in place for a long time.
  • Easy application.
  • Strong tip.
  • Feels heavy.

Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil is perfect for you if you want to have a long lasting waterline eyeliner. If sweat and crying make you panic about the state of your eyes, well this product will remove that worries.

3. Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner

This eyeliner is designed to resist water and emphasize lash lines. Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner has natural honey, hypoallergenic formulation and coconut to assure its best quality.

Moreover, one feature that makes it excel is it quick drying ability. In other words, you don’t need to wait too long before it dries.

  • Applies easily.
  • Pigmented color.
  • Non-irritating.
  • Fades a little couple of hours after application.

Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner is a great buy if you have a very sensitive eyes. Its hypoallergenic property will pamper your eyes to the fullest.

4. 2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set

2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set offers a durable waterproof effect that you will love. The best thing with this product is it comes in set. In other words, you can choose what color you want to use in a day or the other. This best eyeliner for waterline emphasizes the beauty of your eyes.

  • Long lasting.
  • Incredible price.
  • Multi-purpose.
  • Brushes are just fine.

This product is what you are looking for if you want to have a multipurpose set. This can be used in eyebrows or as eyeliners. Surely you will not regret because of its incredible price that comes in two colors already.

5. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner

This pencil eyeliner is designed to last for a long time. L’Oreal Paris Pencil Eyeliner is the best drugstore eyeliner pencil perfect for your eyes. Moreover, it is formulated to resist clumps to give you a perfect look.

  • Doesn’t smear.
  • Long lasting.
  • Comes with beautiful colors.
  • Hardens a little.

L’Oreal Paris Pencil Eyeliner is a great buy if you want to own a long lasting and doesn’t smear make up for your eyes. Its variety of colors are offered for you to choose your color preference. This is the best eyeliner for waterline that doesn’t smudge.

6. Eyeliner Stamp – Winged Eyeliner in Seconds

This eyeliner comes in stamp type. It is very easy to apply. Eyeliner Stamp is the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids since if contains a special formula that is safe for sensitive eyes. Furthermore, this one is a fast drying type that lasts from morning to evening.

  • Quick to apply.
  • Long lasting.
  • Perfect lines.
  • Smudge a little in a very high temperature.

If you are living in a not so hot environment, picking Eyeliner Stamp is perfect for you. This is also the best eyeliner for older women since it is in stamp type. Say goodbye to messy eye liners.

7. SEILANC Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

This eyeliner precisely defines your eye makeup because of its very fine tip. Its water and smudge proof feature will save from embarrassing circumstances. Moreover, this is its auto-controlled ink eyeliner pen prevents ink to leak on your eyelid. This is best eyeliner for beginners.

  • Flexible tip.
  • Water resistant.
  • Easy to apply.
  • Quick drying.
  • Ran out fast.

If you’re looking for best smudge proof eyeliner oily eyelids, this product will be a good choice. This is perfect if you want have a sharp cat-eyes with ease.

Buying Guide – Smudge Proof Eyeliner Oily Eyelids

Since we want to help you pick the best eyeliner for oily skin, here are the buying guides for you to have a good purchase.

Type of Eyeliner

What kind do you prefer to have; liquid, gel, pencil or stamp eyeliner? Consider this question before picking one. Liquid eyeliner intensively emphasize the lines to give you a dramatic make up look.

On the other hand, pencil gives softer lines. This is commonly used to create a more natural appearance. However, gel liner glides on easily upon application. are matte and glide on easily. Lastly, the stamp eyeliner offers a very quick application. You can have a perfect eye lines in no time.

Part of Application

Which part of the eyes you will use the eyeliner? Is it for the eyelids only or for the waterline? Think about the part of the eye you want to put the lines. There better kind of eyeliner in every part you want to place it. Pencil type is best for the eye’s waterline; however, liquid is for the eyelid.

In addition, there are also eyeliners that are good even in your brows. It can be for your waterline, eyelid or for brow emphasis.


Consider the color before placing an eyeliner in your purchase box. Make sure to buy the color that will jive to the color of your skin. Even if the quality of the eyeliner is in its best but when applied to a skin that it looks invisible, it defeats its purpose.

Moreover, the color of your eyes also matter, the eyeliner and the eye color should complement from each other.  For example, if the color of your eyes are blue, brown and gold eyeliners are the best choice.

Temperature of Your Location

One of the most important things you need to consider is the temperature of the place you are in. The time an eyeliner lasts also depends on the warmness or the coldness of the area.

Additionally, make sure that the eyeliner you want to purchase can endure the hotness of the weather in your place. Even if the eyeliner is proven to be long lasting in one place, it is not an assurance that it is true to all areas. Your location also affects.

Sensitivity of Your Eyes

Even if we say that the eyeliner gives perfect lines in your eyes, if you have sensitive eyes, surely you will focus more on its ingredients not on those perfect lines.

In other words, always look for the substances the eyeliner is made of before picking it. There are many eyeliners that are hypoallergenic and made up of organic materials. Prefer to choose organic makeups than synthetic. Most makeups that caused allergies are made up from harsh chemicals.


Don’t forget to check how long lasting is the eyeliner before buying it. There are some that give majestic effect in your eyes but only last for hours. These type need frequent reapplication. Make sure to pick an eyeliner that will not fade even hours passed.


Lastly, consider your style in choosing for an eyeliner. Your fashion also matters in getting one. For example, in doing eye cat, liquid eyeliner is better. You can make nice strokes to have a perfect eye look. However, if you want your eyes to appear bigger, use a pencil eyeliner in your waterline.

Smudge Proof Eyeliner for Oily Eyelids FAQs

For you to make a clear decision about the best eyeliner for you, here are the frequently asked questions with answers.

Q1: Can I leave my eyeliner overnight?

Answer: Leaving eyeliner in your eyelids or waterlines may clog the pores that may cause nasty stye.

Q2: At what temperature should I store my eyeliner?

Answer: Do not place your eyeliner in a place more than 29 degrees Celsius.

Q3: Is it safe to share eyeliner to other people?

Answer: No. Our eyes are potential to infection. Consider eyeliner as your personal belonging.

Q4: What color of eyeliner is best for blue eyes?

Answer: Colors brown and gold give emphasis to blue eyes. It makes the eyes look more majestic.

Q5: Can I use my eyebrow pencil as eyeliner?

Answer: You can. However, make sure to be very careful since eyebrow pencil has harder tip compare to soft tip eyeliner.

Q6: How long before I throw my liquid eyeliner?

Answer: The lifespan of the eyeliner is just like mascara. Use it within six months.

Q7: Can I use wipes without makeup remover in taking away eyeliner from the eye lid?

Answer: Yes you can. But, there are top quality eyeliners that are hard to remove without makeup remover. Just try it first.

Final Verdict

Finding the best eyeliner is hard to do. Promises of the manufacturer are left and right. However, since we want to give you the best, these top 7 Smudge Proof Eyeliner for Oily Eyelids are carefully chosen just for you.

Similar Articles:

Leave a Reply